When the Liberal Party Tweeted policy statements from its Annual General Meeting,
this past weekend, Dwight Ball was essentially telegraphing a message to voters he had no
intention of going near the  minefield
chosen by Ontario Conservative Leader Tim Hudak.

While Hudak may
never win any awards as a strategist, he has also made sure no political leader in Canada will
ever advance risqué ideas when the opposing Party is already on the ropes.

NDP Leader Andrea Horwath brought down the Liberal Government of Kathleen Wynne even
though it proposed a huge deficit which would be added to a large debt. Then, in
a measure akin to ritualistic Harikiri, Conservative Leader Tim Hudak kicked
off the ensuing election campaign by proposing tax cuts of 30% and axing of 100,000
public sector workers.  

The Ontario Liberal
Party was exceedingly unpopular.  Referring to a Study
conducted for the Paper, The Globe and Mail reported that “61 per cent of people who cast
ballots agreed it was “time for a change in the Ontario government,” next to
only 21 per cent who disagreed.” 

Premier Dalton McGuinty chalked up a record of lost jobs and lost industry,
deficit spending, a costly and failed energy strategy as well as charges of
corruption that saw the police search his former offices.  McGuinty’s low polling numbers fit well when placed
alongside those of former Premier Kathy Dunderdale. 

But when the
election was held last Thursday 12 June the Liberals were returned with a
majority Government. 

When so many
Ontario Liberals, who thought it “time for a change” stuck with the Party it wanted to be rid of you
know that the Tory Opposition had seriously miscalculated.

Hudak might
have let the Liberals fall on their sword.  That’s exactly the strategy Dwight Ball has been working on, with the Tories, since he became Leader. 

While the
Tories have steeped Ball in opportunity he has always been reluctant to take
the bridle of leadership even when marginal issues offered advantage.  

Never one to
condemn the Muskrat Falls Project, he skirted around even peripheral issues having
either bought Ed Martin’s “spin” or felt conflicted by pro-Muskrat insiders. He
was careful to recognize that two-thirds of the population support the Project;
most of them without a sweet clue how it might impact them. 

He has spent
a short time on the “Oversight” issue but has given it no staying power.

Even on the
Humber Valley Paving scandal, Ball gave it little attention once the Auditor
General was engaged, possibly seeing no merit in causing political damage to
transitional Premier Tom Marshall.

Ball has simply never differentiated issues when it comes to an assessment of political
risk.  He eschews all risk.

It is one
thing to avoid the advancement of ideas that might mortally wound one’s political
survival, as in the case of Tim Hudak, but those issues should never be
confused with the importance of advancing others that demonstrate talent, prove
leadership or that simply keep the Government honest. 

Ball may be
savvy enough not to rain on the public’s parade of ‘good
times’; debt and deficit notwithstanding. The question is: will he ever be able
to communicate bad news when that is the right thing to do. Will he be able to prescribe bitter medicine?

following policy Tweets from the Liberal Convention demonstrate Ball’s ‘soft’ approach, one that might command more accurate descriptions like ‘mushy’ and ‘mother-hood’:

Ball –
Liberals believe in the dream we all share, that home will always be home.
#nlpoli #nlliberals #AGM2014
Ball – We
will take mental health as seriously as physical health. #nlpoli #nlliberals
Ball –
Liberals will move province away from reliance on mega-projects. #nlpoli
#nlliberals #AGM2014
Ball – Our
policy will ensure the people of #Labrador share equally in the benefits of
their resources. #nlpoli #nlliberals #AGM2014
Ball – A
Liberal government will never give up on our fishery. #nlpoli #nlliberals  #AGM 2014
Ball –
Health care providers say money already in the system – we just need to spend
it smarter #nlpoli #nlliberals #AGM2014
Ball – Over
time we will lower cost of health care & improve quality with NO CUTS.
#nlpoli #nlliberals #AGM2014

Don’t they make you you feel
emboldened! “Never give up on the fishery”, lowering the costs of health care
with “NO CUTS”, “move… away from reliance on mega projects”; wouldn’t you just wish a ballot box were
close by!

Of course, besides the Tories’ unpopularity, Ball has one
other advantage which will compound his propensity to pull him back from any experiment with much needed (forget risky) public policy change. The Ontario Liberal Party chose a Leader who proved
to be intuitive and even “likeable”.  For
certain, Wynne is a skilful communicator capable of embracing rather than
isolating her electorate. 

The Tories
have Frank Coleman, a recluse tainted by the HVP affair, whom the SRB Papers Blog has already dubbed the ‘peek-a-boo’ Premier.

If you had
thought there might be some public policy options advanced by the
Liberal Party in the next election, that is less likely than ever.  The Tories have the support of just 29% of
voters and they have Frank Coleman. 

The Liberals are not just careful; they are
content.  While Ball told his troops not to get too “cocky” the bigger problem may be his own: his claim to caution suggests he stands for little.

His caution
many cause a fickle electorate to see him as too weak just as Ontario’s voters thought
Hudak over the top.

Dwight Ball needs
to dig deeper. The Ontario electorate certainly did.
Des Sullivan
Des Sullivan
St. John's, Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada Uncle Gnarley is hosted by Des Sullivan, of St. John's. He is a businessman engaged over three decades in real estate management and development companies and in retail. He is currently a Director of Dorset Investments Limited and Donovan Holdings Limited. During his early career he served as Executive Assistant to Premier's Frank D. Moores (1975-1979) and Brian Peckford (1979-1985). He also served as a Part-Time Board Member on the Canada-Newfoundland Labrador Offshore Petroleum Board (C-NLOPB). Uncle Gnarley appears on the masthead representing serious and unambiguous positions on NL politics and public policy. Uncle Gnarley is a fiscal conservative possessing distinctly liberal values and a non-partisan persusasion. Those values and opinions underlie this writer's views on NL's politics, economy and society. Uncle Gnarley publishes Monday mornings and more often when events warrant.


Bill left public life shortly after the signing of the Atlantic Accord and became a member of the Court of Appeal until his retirement in 2003. During his time on the court he was involved in a number of successful appeals which overturned wrongful convictions, for which he was recognized by Innocence Canada. Bill had a special place in his heart for the underdog.

Churchill Falls Explainer (Coles Notes version)

If CFLCo is required to maximize its profit, then CFLCo should sell its electricity to the highest bidder(s) on the most advantageous terms available.


This is the most important set of negotiations we have engaged in since the Atlantic Accord and Hibernia. Despite being a small jurisdiction we proved to be smart and nimble enough to negotiate good deals on both. They have stood the test of time and have resulted in billions of dollars in royalties and created an industry which represents over a quarter of our economy. Will we prove to be smart and nimble enough to do the same with the Upper Churchill?


  1. Clyde Wells once said he knew exactly what had to be done for Newfoundland, but he just did not have the political will to do it. The next 5-10 years will be critical in Newfoundland's history as the discussion will have to change from the survival of rural Newfoundland, to how do we effectiently euthanize the many small communities that now only home seniors and the unemployed. This is the discussion that no one wants to have, but is one that we must start to consider. The social impacts of caring for communities of 80 year olds, whose children live thousands of kilometers away, is just starting to manifest itself. It will be a major issue in a decade, in 2 decades it will be a crisis.

    Aside from our demographics we also need someone to wake up and look at our irrational spending habit. From 400 million investments for new science buildings at MUN, to the unpredcendented increase in the size of the public service we need to have a full stop. We need to objectively look at the sustainability of our spending. It is not sustainable.

    This PC government of the past 10 years has been a disaster on almost every major file. they have spent like sailors, with little to show.

  2. I agree with the views you have put forward. At the very least, Dwight Ball needs to make sure the people of the province will have an opportunity to see the full story on such disastrous projects as Muskrat Fall. While canning the project may not be feasible, he should at the very lease provide full disclosure on the financial and other impacts for the province. And where it is shown that incompetence and miss management by individuals behind the project brought on this array of problems, they will be dealt with in due course.

    There is no magic bullet to solve the many problems that face the province, but an open and steady resolve to grapple the issues, will go a long way in trying to improve the current situation and lesson the pain for all. The PC party has squandered hundreds of millions of dollars and where did that get us. It's time to regroup and set a course that is sustainable and one that will hopefully show promise for the many graduates who want to work and make a life at home.

  3. Dwight Ball, (Newfoundland's own Dash Riprock) and Frank Coleman ( Barney Rubble's portrayal of Sleepy Dwarf) have certainly have one thing in common! "Boring politicians" – if I can use that term "politician" very loosely, most especially in Coleman's case.

    OMG! Seriously, can you imagine the four years of politics in Newfoundland after the next general election? Dwight's makeup and wardrobe people give him the thumbs up and he stands, looks directly at the House cameras, to tell all Newfoundlanders that Foggy and Snowy weather is lovely and he is looking at selling some of our Fog and Snow to less privileged people on our wonderful earth. Dwight sits down and the cameras turn and zoom in on Coleman who is sound asleep, with his cell phone at his ear and he can be heard mumbling something like, "Dam Dominion and Sobeys!"

    This is not going to be fun and the astute politician minding Newfoundlanders will be no more!

  4. Anonymous, Clyde Wells did not say that. Brian Peckford did. In fact, what Peckford said was that he knew what had to be done, but did not have the "necessary ruthlessness" to do it. Wells, however, did have the necessary ruthlessness for the needed cuts, as well as the creative vision to establish the Economic Recovery Commission.

    • And a set of "balls" would be an asset. How can Ball or anyone for that matter, say that the Muskrat Falls project can't be stopped…when not a single person outside the pc CAUCUS (AND I DOUBT EVEN MANY OF THEM) know what the actual expenditure is up to now, and what it is proposed to be in the end. Until we know that, no one can say whether or not muskrat falls can or should be stopped. Which, my friends, is exactly why the PC's and Danny Williams enacted the laws to prevent us from knowing. Ball will be as bad, if not worse, than Dunderdale… What a fiasco! I wonder if true leadership will EVER return to Newfoundland. Time for Labrador to opt out and get on with our own mistakes… at least we would only have ourselves to blame!