Kennedy tendered his resignation, from the House of Assembly and from Cabinet,
yesterday.  We should thank him for his
services and wish him well. 

But, in his case, we ought to first wag a bony finger in his general direction, and give him a good scolding.

That is unfortunate after six
years of public service and four senior Cabinet positions.  Still, Mr. Kennedy has little to show for his
hiatus from the practice of law.

That his
departure ranked second, Wednesday, on the CBC 6 O’clock News to a bed bug
infestation, was a most unkind cut; one Dunderdale’s new PR man could never have
thought devising.

Perhaps, the
CBC, too, barely thought the announcement news. Mr. Kennedy’s preference to
leave politics was the talk of garden parties in his District, this past
summer.  His early return, from the
Premier’s China junket, spoke to a none-too-private disagreement with her.  An earlier dust-up in Caucus, following his
irreverent comments on the sanctity (or otherwise) of the Tory Blue Book, did
little to endear him to his colleagues. 

All are tired
of his missteps, though they feign unity in the face of an uninspiring boss and
a tired Administration. 

Tory Members
are suffering fatigue from the public backlash of budget flip-flops, poor
communications, an unyielding arrogance, a secrecy exemplified by Bill 29 and
an Alice in Wonderland style of thinking. 
As this Government enters mid-term, the Dunderdale Government has
neither imagination nor energy; it is a spent force.

Hence, Mr.
Kennedy’s desire to leave Government was a question of ‘when’ not ‘if’.  His former colleagues will shed no tears; his
pit-bull demeanor having done little to enhance his or their public image. At
first, he was protected by Danny but Dunderdale seems to have had the same
empathy for sooks, as she displays for everyone else.

It must be
said that Mr. Kennedy came to the Williams’ Government having had some distinguishing
moments in the practice of law.  Much was
expected of him in a Cabinet that never earned a reputation for being over-qualified. 

in the Dunderdale Cabinet, it was thought he might punch above his weight,
along with his lawyer colleague, Tom Marshall. 
Though the Premier thought them the best of the lot, and endowed them
with the senior Portfolios, their inability to manage demanding issues,
especially Muskrat Falls, deficit spending and the fall-out from over-spending repair,
disappointed even their most ardent partisans.

Years of
listening to clients and giving them legal counsel failed to translate into a willingness
to give the public its right to demand respect, communication, leadership and
articulation of their worst fears, all of which represent the best trademarks
of political life. Kennedy might have been expected to compensate for an ill-prepared
Premier, help her devise strategy and bring much needed wisdom to key public
policies.  But, he showed little interest
in the minutiae that underpins both the art and the science of Government.  Then, too, like his insecure boss he had little
patience for detractors. 

As it is,
the most expensive and potentially injurious megaproject, in the history of the
Province, is being fed from the public trough, as those responsible for paying
the bill are ignorant of its purpose and its final cost.

Hence, the
problem of the Dunderdale Administration is not just about the Premier.
Kennedy’s own shortcomings have helped define the most incompetent Government
in decades.


Yet, his
decision to depart now leaves one with a sense of bafflement and incredulity.
He has abandoned his cabinet colleagues at a time when the Government’s
satisfaction rating is at its lowest.  The
timing of his resignation, not just from Cabinet but from the House of
Assembly, too, risks further embarrassing the Premier in a legally required by-election.

In severing
his ties completely, Kennedy confirmed that the sweetness and light, which
characterized their appearance in front of the media, was just for the cameras.

I submit there
is more to this story than a Minister bored.

Government is immersed in an unwise, hugely expensive and risk laden Muskrat
Falls Project.  It was prematurely
sanctioned.  It appears ready to go off
the rails any day.  Financing for the
Project is not secured, neither is the Federal Loan Guarantee; serious law
suits threaten.  Emera is a reluctant
partner, too, and its price for participating is extremely high. The NS UARB
has upped the ante even further, to a level one lawyer described as “extortionist”.

A billion
dollars has already been spent, another billion committed and a million or more
is added each day the sun sets.  The
Minister’s resignation has all the hallmarks of one leaving a sinking ship.

The Premier
has no one in Cabinet who possesses either knowledge of the issues or the
intellectual depth to get up to speed on a matter very complex.  Which of them will fence with Ed Martin after
only forty eight hours on the file?  The
only person a new Finance Minister can trust, his Deputy, is as divorced from the subject
as the night janitor.  It is a worrisome affair. 

Only eight
months ago, Tom Marshall asked to be moved out of Finance; not having possessed
the character and decisiveness demanded by that portfolio. The Premier can
hardly force the man to go back.

It is a fine
mess that Jerome Kennedy leaves, even if it is partly his own creation. 

One might suggest that he owed it to the Government, to his constituents and
to the people of the Province, to have helped clean it up before leaving.    

The ability to change course, to recognize a more sensible, less risky path may simply not have been within the skill-set of one so dogmatic.

Having abandoned what he helped begin, if he is wrong on Muskrat Falls, he has only a lifetime of enmity to which to look forward. 
Des Sullivan
Des Sullivan
St. John's, Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada Uncle Gnarley is hosted by Des Sullivan, of St. John's. He is a businessman engaged over three decades in real estate management and development companies and in retail. He is currently a Director of Dorset Investments Limited and Donovan Holdings Limited. During his early career he served as Executive Assistant to Premier's Frank D. Moores (1975-1979) and Brian Peckford (1979-1985). He also served as a Part-Time Board Member on the Canada-Newfoundland Labrador Offshore Petroleum Board (C-NLOPB). Uncle Gnarley appears on the masthead representing serious and unambiguous positions on NL politics and public policy. Uncle Gnarley is a fiscal conservative possessing distinctly liberal values and a non-partisan persusasion. Those values and opinions underlie this writer's views on NL's politics, economy and society. Uncle Gnarley publishes Monday mornings and more often when events warrant.


Bill left public life shortly after the signing of the Atlantic Accord and became a member of the Court of Appeal until his retirement in 2003. During his time on the court he was involved in a number of successful appeals which overturned wrongful convictions, for which he was recognized by Innocence Canada. Bill had a special place in his heart for the underdog.

Churchill Falls Explainer (Coles Notes version)

If CFLCo is required to maximize its profit, then CFLCo should sell its electricity to the highest bidder(s) on the most advantageous terms available.


This is the most important set of negotiations we have engaged in since the Atlantic Accord and Hibernia. Despite being a small jurisdiction we proved to be smart and nimble enough to negotiate good deals on both. They have stood the test of time and have resulted in billions of dollars in royalties and created an industry which represents over a quarter of our economy. Will we prove to be smart and nimble enough to do the same with the Upper Churchill?


  1. During the house debate on Muskrat Falls, Kennedy said, in regard to knowing the forecast demand on the island for this power was correct " Here's a simple legal trick I use… you just look into the crystal ball". This trick, in Kennedy's mind, replaces "best practices" for forecasting. Manitoba Hydro said Nalcor was deficient in some areas of their forecasting, and not meeting some best practices. In essence, Kennedy's crystal ball words had more effect that the logic of using best practises. I will forever remember him for these words and think of him as Crystal Ball Kennedy. Too bad really. He also said yesterday that he looked under every rock, (or similar words), to see where the downside of MF might be, and could find none. Guess he never looked at the New England Efficiency Plans….. taking the equivalent of a MF off the line almost every year, at one seventh the cost of MF power. Maybe that was his problem, he looked under rocks instead of assessing reliable sources. I filed a submission with the PUB on the value of Efficiency….. that paper wasn't under a rock. Perhaps the Telegram guy should do a cartoon with Kennedy looking at his crystal ball, or under a rock , searching for information on Efficiency, demand forecast, and best practices. Winston Adams

  2. 50% of the NLPC Ministers that had a grasp on MF (however warped) is leaving mid term before the House reopens, the other 50% isn't running in 2015.

    For the singularity most important capital works project since Confederation, shouldn't ALL of the NLPC MHAs be well versed on all of the issues surrounding MF?

    Did Kennedy's legal training speak up on the issue of sanctioning MF blindly without PPAs or legal clarification on WMA issues?

    Crystal ball for $125 oil in the budget never materialized, why is this method still being used for electricity demand?

    NLPCs have been hiding under a rock since DW left and in October 2015 they will be shattered by a giant sledgehammer(voters) perhaps facing a royal commission or 2 for their incompetence,

  3. Kennedy will be remembered for his intellect. Relatively speaking he was a genious. Yet his stubbordness on Muskrat Falls will frame his political portrait. He did not do his job as minister of the crown to challenge what was being offered. He handcuffed the PUB, and he bypassed due process. Now as Muskrat Falls implodes under the weight of poor decisions he leaves for greener pastures. Maybe he saw the light, maybe he was just tired. Bully or Genious…. time will tell.

  4. I think Kennedy is rather intelligent, but not a genius. In the house debate on whether we will need this MF power on the island, he opted to highlight some supporting material, like more and bigger houses, while ignoring new house efficiency codes which is slashing energy use. Proper forecasting must include end use analysis, which is best practises which other utilities use. This is evidence bases analysis. This was a key flaw pointed out by Manitoba Hydro. Its value is confirmed by the strides New England is making in demand reduction and savings for their customers, and deferral of new expensive power generation. If Kennedy was a genius, or just open minded, he would have seen and understood these as substancial problems. I suspect he was subject to tunnel vision, which he accused others of when police convicted the wrong people. Winston Adams